When you are as divisive a historical figure as Margaret Thatcher, it is no surprise that a film about your life will be met with equally mixed responses.
Historical biopics have fallen out of favor with many of the younger generations, while conservative supporters of Thatcher aren’t going to be happy unless the film portrays her as a saint.
For me, a pure political accounting of Thatcher’s rule would have felt abhorrent to my liberal sensibilities, and so I was thankful that the film chose instead to explore the challenges of breaking into the old boy’s club, and used the tropes of losing one’s spouse and reflecting back upon one’s life to give the story a universal appeal. Her allies may worry that the film made her look weak, but for me it humanized her decisions and helped to explain the fears that informed her policies.
Meryl Streep was superb as we’ve come to expect, and I thoroughly enjoyed the humor that Jim Broadbent brought to the role of Denis Thatcher (a portrayal that grows on you and pays off fully in the final scenes of the film.) The film explores the discipline and perfectionism that underdogs often feel they have to live up to in order to make it, as well as the dreadful consequences of insisting upon that ethic once one has become the overlord.
Oscar Chances:
If the real-life Meryl Streep were more like Margaret Thatcher, she may well have won an additional Oscar by now, but she probably would have received fewer nominations. Streep graciously acknowledges her fellow actresses, and appears to make a point of using her success to highlight the work of others and make their path easier. Thatcher’s motto would have been “I’ve worked hard, and you should too”, and she certainly wouldn’t be listing other actress’ achievements in her precursor acceptance speeches, or even showing up for the SAG awards, being a labor guild and all. Thatcher would have been hard-nosed enough to secure wins, but people would have hated her for it, and certainly not nominated her as often or over as many years.
In this year’s race, I am currently predicting that Meryl Streep will narrowly come in second to her good friend Viola Davis, but that the film will win over Harry Potter for the excellent makeup work done by Mark Coulier and J. Roy Helland.
As always, check the Tracker Pages in the upper right hand corner of this blog for the most updated predictions in all categories!
My Lamb Score: 4 out of 5 Lambs
What is a lamb score? Click HERE to learn more.
Read recent reviews HERE, or search the Archives.
You sent me back to check me own Lambscore! LOL. (My letter grades dont always equate well) I gave it a 2.5. I knew you seemed like you liked it a lot more than I did.
ReplyDeleteThe directing really got in the way here, for me.
But I'll agree to everything you said about Streep, she was well deservant of the nomination.
Thanks! I have found that I tend to give higher scores to films with really great acting, and I usually like biopics more than most folks, so I'm not surprised to find myself on the higher end of the scale here.
DeleteStreep’s performance is so true and so uncannily accurate, so full and so complete in its understanding, that she is fascinating every second she is onscreen. As for the film itself, the structure is a bit off and the screenplay doesn’t really give us much else other than a history lesson, but a good history lesson at that. Nice review right here.
ReplyDeleteThanks Dan! Nothing wrong with a history lesson in my opinion!
DeleteI think regardless of how one feels about Thatcher, you've got to admit she led a fascinating life, especially in a profession dominated by men. I'll rent this one and though I have no doubt Meryl gave an astounding performance, I felt like someone else should take home the Oscar.
ReplyDeleteThanks Ruth! It is indeed a fascinating life, and I think the film does a good job of showing her rise to power, even showing a scene where she herself can't believe she's breaking into the boy's club.
DeleteWhat I keep hearing is that Streep gives a great performance in a relatively mediocre movie. I'm not sure I want to spend time on these kind of movies, more particularly when they are biopics. Your review might tempt me to give it a rental down the road though.
ReplyDeleteThanks Castor. I am finding over time that I definitely have different tastes in movies than a lot of the blogosphere. Biopics with great performances are among some of my favorites, for example!
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI quite enjoyed this film. I feel like watching it again just for Meryl's performance. It was astonishing. She has amazing screen presence, you can't look at anyone else. Such a gifted actress. I hope she wins the Oscar (although I'm a big Viola Davis fan).
DeleteI'm glad to hear that you liked it too, as many folks seem to be a little harsh on the film as a whole. Meryl is fantastic and certainly deserving of an award this year, even more than she usually does!
Delete